12 Best Whiskies for an Old Fashioned

When it comes to crafting the perfect Old Fashioned, the choice of whiskey is paramount. The classic cocktail is a testament to simplicity, relying on the harmonious blend of whiskey, sugar, bitters, and a twist of citrus.

But not all whiskies are created equal, and the right one can elevate your Old Fashioned from good to unforgettable. Whether you’re a seasoned whiskey aficionado or just starting to explore the world of spirits, here are 12 of the best whiskies to consider for your next Old Fashioned.

Quick Answer

For most Old Fashioneds, reach for a bourbon or rye bottled between 90 and 100 proof: strong enough to stand up to the sugar, bitters and melting ice without drowning them out. Pick a rye such as Rittenhouse or Sazerac if you like a spicier, drier drink, a wheated bourbon like Maker’s Mark for a softer and sweeter one, and a bold, higher-proof pour like Wild Turkey 101 or Old Forester 100 Proof if you want the whiskey front and center. Only looking at bourbon? See our best bourbons for an Old Fashioned.

The 12 Whiskeys at a Glance

12 Whiskies to Consider for Your Next Old Fashioned

1. Bulleit Bourbon

Bulleit Bourbon is a top choice for many Old Fashioned enthusiasts. Known for its high rye content, Bulleit offers a spicy kick that balances beautifully with the sweetness of the sugar and the bitterness of the Angostura. Its robust flavor stands up well in the cocktail, making every sip a delight.

>> Try Your Old Fashioned Smoked with a Cocktail Smoker from Aged & Charred

2. Woodford Reserve

Woodford Reserve is a classic bourbon with a rich, full-bodied flavor profile. Its notes of dried fruit, vanilla, and toffee provide a perfect backdrop for an Old Fashioned. The complexity of Woodford Reserve ensures that each ingredient in the cocktail shines without overpowering the others.

3. Buffalo Trace

Buffalo Trace is a versatile bourbon that’s smooth enough to enjoy neat but also works wonderfully in an Old Fashioned. Its hints of caramel, vanilla, and a slight smokiness make it a crowd-pleaser. Buffalo Trace’s balance of sweetness and spice is ideal for those who prefer a slightly sweeter Old Fashioned.

4. Rittenhouse Rye

For those who prefer their Old Fashioned with a bit more bite, Rittenhouse Rye is the way to go. This high-proof rye whisky delivers a punchy, spicy flavor that cuts through the sweetness of the sugar. Its boldness is perfect for those who like their cocktails with a bit of an edge.

5. Old Forester 100 Proof

Old Forester 100 Proof is a bourbon that holds its own in any cocktail. Its high proof ensures that the whiskey’s flavors don’t get lost among the other ingredients. Expect rich notes of oak, spice, and a hint of sweetness that makes it a favorite for an Old Fashioned.

6. Eagle Rare 10 Year

Eagle Rare 10 Year is a bourbon with depth and character. Aged for a decade, it brings a refined complexity to the Old Fashioned. With notes of candied almonds, vanilla, and a touch of leather, Eagle Rare adds a layer of sophistication to the cocktail.

7. Knob Creek 9 Year

Knob Creek 9 Year is a small-batch bourbon that packs a flavorful punch. Its bold flavors of oak, caramel, and a hint of smoke are perfectly balanced, making it a strong contender for an Old Fashioned. The whiskey’s rich character stands up well to the other ingredients, creating a well-rounded cocktail.

8. Sazerac Rye

Sazerac Rye is another excellent choice for those who love a spicier Old Fashioned. This rye whiskey is named after the famous New Orleans cocktail, but it’s just as at home in an Old Fashioned. With its peppery spice and smooth finish, Sazerac Rye adds a delightful complexity to the drink.

9. Four Roses Single Barrel

Four Roses Single Barrel is a premium bourbon that delivers a unique flavor profile with each bottle. The single barrel nature of this whiskey means that no two bottles are exactly alike, but you can always expect a smooth, rich bourbon with hints of ripe fruit, spice, and vanilla. It’s an excellent choice for those who enjoy a bit of variety in their Old Fashioned.

10. Elijah Craig Small Batch

Elijah Craig Small Batch is a bourbon with a warm, rich flavor that’s perfect for an Old Fashioned. Its notes of caramel, vanilla, and a hint of spice make it a well-balanced choice. Elijah Craig’s smooth finish ensures that your Old Fashioned is as enjoyable from the first sip to the last.

11. Maker’s Mark

Maker’s Mark is known for its smooth, easy-drinking quality. Its soft wheat profile makes it a bit sweeter than other bourbons, which can complement the sugar and bitters in an Old Fashioned nicely. Maker’s Mark is a great option for those who prefer a milder, sweeter cocktail.

12. Wild Turkey 101

Wild Turkey 101 is a high-proof bourbon with a bold flavor profile. It brings a punch of spice, oak, and caramel to your Old Fashioned. The higher alcohol content means that the whiskey’s flavors won’t be overshadowed by the other ingredients, making it a strong choice for those who like a robust cocktail.

The Role of Whiskey Proof in Crafting an Old Fashioned

The alcohol content of a whiskey can dramatically influence both the taste and strength of your Old Fashioned. A higher proof whiskey brings with it a potent kick and bold flavors, commanding attention with each sip. Conversely, a whiskey with lower alcohol content imparts a softer, sometimes smoother drinking experience, allowing for a more nuanced interplay of ingredients.

But where does one find the harmonious point where whiskey proof marries perfectly with the other components of an Old Fashioned? Typically, whiskeys that sit between 90 and 100 proof strike an exquisite balance.

These whiskeys provide enough backbone to stand up to the dilution from melting ice, while not overpowering the palate with alcohol, allowing the symphony of bitters, sugar, and citrus to sing through.

Varying proofs should not be overlooked as an avenue for personal preference and exploration. As you embark on crafting your Old Fashioned, consider how the nuances of your chosen whiskey's proof will enhance the integrity of your cocktail.

Will the higher proof of a cask-strength whiskey bring a welcomed vigor to your glass, or will a mid-range proof create just the right environment for your taste buds to savor each element? Reflect on how the intensity of the whiskey acts as the cocktail's foundation, setting the stage for a memorable experience.

• High-proof whiskeys intensify the cocktail's character.
• Mid-proof whiskeys offer balance, making them an ideal starting point for experimentation.
• Low-proof whiskeys can be appropriate for those seeking a milder cocktail.

Adjusting the proof of your whiskey can transform your Old Fashioned from a soothing slow sipper to a bold statement piece in your cocktail repertoire. Allow yourself the freedom to explore the spectrum of whiskeys available, and watch as the proof influences the ultimate expression of this timeless drink.

Whichever whiskey you land on, pair it with a good Old Fashioned mix so every drink comes out balanced, or go all in with our Ultimate Old Fashioned Kit, which bundles the syrup with Amarena-style cherries and dehydrated orange slices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is bourbon or rye better for an Old Fashioned?

Both are classic. Bourbon makes a rounder, sweeter drink with caramel and vanilla, while rye brings more spice and bite that cuts through the sugar. If you are torn, start with a high-rye bourbon such as Bulleit, which sits right in between.

What proof whiskey is best for an Old Fashioned?

Between 90 and 100 proof is the sweet spot: enough backbone to handle the dilution from melting ice without overpowering the bitters, sugar and citrus. Higher-proof bottles make a bolder drink, lower-proof ones a milder one.

What else do you need besides the whiskey?

The classic recipe is just sugar, bitters and a twist of citrus. For a shortcut, our Old Fashioned mix already balances the sweetness with orange zest, cherry and aromatic bitters: pour 1/4 ounce into your glass, add 2 ounces of your bourbon or rye, then ice and a garnish.

Conclusion

Choosing the right whiskey for an Old Fashioned is all about balancing the flavors you enjoy most. Whether you prefer the spicy kick of a rye, the smooth sweetness of a wheated bourbon, or the complex notes of a well-aged whisky, there’s a perfect bottle out there for you. The next time you’re mixing up an Old Fashioned, consider trying one of these 12 whiskies to take your cocktail experience to the next level.

Found your bottle? See it star in the best Old Fashioned we’ve ever had.

Cheers!